Pro-life activists oppose 'ridiculous' proposal from bioethicists to force doctors to kill babies

A pro-life supporter holds up a sign during a rally in New York. Reuters

In Canada, two bioethicists have proposed that doctors be forced to perform abortions in hospital even if it's against their will, triggering a howl of protests from pro-life advocates who called the proposal "ridiculous."

Bioethicists Udo Schuklenk from Queen's University and Julian Savulescu from Oxford University recently proposed that doctors be stripped of their rights to refuse performing abortion procedures on patients who ask for them.

"Doctors must put patients' interests ahead of their own integrity. If this leads to feelings of guilty remorse or them dropping out of the profession, so be it," the academics said in an article published in "Bioethics," as quoted by Life Site News.

The researchers added that this will not result in fewer doctors, since many students seek to become medical practitioners. They also said that medical schools should not accept students who will make decisions based on moral grounds once they become doctors.

Pro-life advocate Alex Schadenberg, however, opposed these suggestions, maintaining that Canada's Constitution "recognises conscience rights."

"Someone can go up, put in their order and they can get what they want. But to me that's a ridiculous situation. Human beings should never be treated like computers, nor are they like that," Schadenberg told Life Site News.

Christian Elia, executive director of the Catholic Civil Rights League, also did not agree with the bioethicists' proposal, saying medical practitioners should never be forced to violate their own conscience.

"Does anybody truly believe that the overall practice of medicine would somehow be enriched if the only practitioners were technocrats who had no moral compass, no sense of reasoning, no conscience, and did not even consider it important or not to act with integrity?" Elia said.

He added that different views in the field of medicine should be respected, even the belief that abortion is not a necessary medical procedure.

related articles
Saved by their mother from abortion, twin brothers now \'defend the God of life\' as priests
Saved by their mother from abortion, twin brothers now 'defend the God of life' as priests

Saved by their mother from abortion, twin brothers now 'defend the God of life' as priests

Bishops in Nigeria warn government against promoting culture of contraception, abortion
Bishops in Nigeria warn government against promoting culture of contraception, abortion

Bishops in Nigeria warn government against promoting culture of contraception, abortion

Beauty queen thanks parents\' faith in God for decision not to abort her despite her disability
Beauty queen thanks parents' faith in God for decision not to abort her despite her disability

Beauty queen thanks parents' faith in God for decision not to abort her despite her disability

Matt Barber explains why Christians should not be \'pro-choice\'
Matt Barber explains why Christians should not be 'pro-choice'

Matt Barber explains why Christians should not be 'pro-choice'

Pro-life billboards inside Catholic cemetery in Canada vandalised, but caretakers choose not to be angry
Pro-life billboards inside Catholic cemetery in Canada vandalised, but caretakers choose not to be angry

Pro-life billboards inside Catholic cemetery in Canada vandalised, but caretakers choose not to be angry

News
Illinois community coming together to purchase Pope's old home
Illinois community coming together to purchase Pope's old home

Debt-hit town in Illinois is looking to buy the Pope's childhood home.

Fear, denial and control: Why the Cuban government prohibits the most natural responses to the country’s dire humanitarian needs
Fear, denial and control: Why the Cuban government prohibits the most natural responses to the country’s dire humanitarian needs

It may be hard to fathom how such pettiness plays into the government’s wider crackdown on FoRB and other fundamental human rights, or how on earth it could justify extending its repression to children, but ultimately it all comes down to fear.

On striving for destiny
On striving for destiny

Hebrew scholar and Jewish academic Irene Lancaster reflects on Numbers, leadership and destiny.