Oregon bakery owners press fight for their religious beliefs, take case to appeals court

Couple Melissa and Aaron Klein are the Christian owners of Sweet Cakes Bakery. (Sweet Cakes Bakery)

It was a big blow for Oregon bakery owners Aaron and Melissa Klein when a court ordered them to cough up $135,000 for refusing to make a cake for a same-sex wedding, but the Christian couple are not backing down from their beliefs.

The two have now taken their case before the Oregon Court of Appeals, according to the Gospel Herald. They are being represented by First Liberty (formerly known as Liberty Institute), a legal organisation dedicated to defending and restoring religious liberty.

"We're praying that the state of Oregon will back off," First Liberty attorney Jeremy Dys said on Tuesday. "We're hoping the state will recognise the freedom of religion—we're hoping that it can be restored, not just for us, but for everybody in this nation. We're going to continue to fight on."

The case all started back in 2013, when same-sex couple Laurel and Rachel Bowman-Cryer filed a lawsuit against the Kleins and their shop Sweet Cakes Bakery after the Christian couple refused to provide the cake for their wedding, citing their religious beliefs as the reason.

Oregon's Bureau of Labor and Industries sided with the same-sex couple, ruling that the Kleins violated the state's anti-discrimination laws since their bakery is not a registered religious institution.

Aaron said he and his wife do not regret making that decision even if it had cost them their life's savings. "We wanted to honour God with our business, and dedicated everything to him," he said. "We believe in a Biblical definition of marriage, and we believe that we have the freedom of religion in this country."

When the Kleins were forced to pay state-ordered damage fees and interest totalling $136,927.07 in December 2015, it was a good thing that a crowdfunding site such as the Samaritan's Purse gave them financial aid.

"The government of Oregon cleaned out their bank account to penalise them without their permission, but that wasn't enough," Dys said. "Thankfully, they had a whole bunch of crowdfunding that came alongside them and they were able to pay the penalty that they had to pay in order to appeal this."

They now have a chance to turn things around at the Oregon Court of Appeals. First Liberty revealed that legal briefs are expected to be filed throughout the year, adding that their oral argument will take place late this year.

"This is something that is broader than just these two people," Dys said. "If it can happen to Aaron and Melissa at a bakery shop, it can happen to anybody at any level of employment at any business. The government should never be the ones coercing individuals into believing something that they don't believe. Or, for that matter, punishing them for believing it. All of America suffers when someone loses their religious liberty."

related articles
Christian bakers violated gay couple\'s rights, say Oregon officials
Christian bakers violated gay couple's rights, say Oregon officials

Christian bakers violated gay couple's rights, say Oregon officials

Gay advocate is fundraising to help Christian bakers pay off $150k fines for refusing lesbian couple\'s wedding cake order
Gay advocate is fundraising to help Christian bakers pay off $150k fines for refusing lesbian couple's wedding cake order

Gay advocate is fundraising to help Christian bakers pay off $150k fines for refusing lesbian couple's wedding cake order

Oregon bakers fined $135,000 for refusing gay wedding cake  \'will not relent\'
Oregon bakers fined $135,000 for refusing gay wedding cake 'will not relent'

Oregon bakers fined $135,000 for refusing gay wedding cake 'will not relent'

Christian bakers blast Oregon gag order as they draw huge online funding support
Christian bakers blast Oregon gag order as they draw huge online funding support

Christian bakers blast Oregon gag order as they draw huge online funding support

Oregon bakers sued by lesbian couple  believe God will eventually triumph
Oregon bakers sued by lesbian couple believe God will eventually triumph

Oregon bakers sued by lesbian couple believe God will eventually triumph

News
Church of England directs £600,000 towards clergy mental health and financial support
Church of England directs £600,000 towards clergy mental health and financial support

The funding package includes new grants for two national charities working with clergy facing psychological strain and financial pressure.

St William shrine fragments return to York Minster after 500 years underground
St William shrine fragments return to York Minster after 500 years underground

Fragments of a long-lost medieval shrine honouring St William of York have returned to York Minster for the first time in nearly 500 years, marking a major moment in the cathedral’s history and a highlight of its programme for 2026.

New research sheds light on why women are more religious than men
New research sheds light on why women are more religious than men

Gender gaps were found to narrow in line with degrees of modernisation, secularisation, and gender equality. But, the paper finds, the "gap does not vanish entirely – even in highly secular countries women remain more religious than men".

Prince and Princess of Wales visit Lambeth Palace to meet new Archbishop of Canterbury
Prince and Princess of Wales visit Lambeth Palace to meet new Archbishop of Canterbury

The Prince and Princess of Wales have paid an official visit to Lambeth Palace.