Only a quarter of evangelicals support blanket ban on abortion

 (Photo: Unsplash/Liv Bruce)

Only a quarter of US evangelicals believe that abortion should be illegal in all cases, a new study has found. 

A third of self-identifying evangelicals surveyed by pro-life group Save the Storks agreed that abortion should be illegal in most cases, while 15% said it should be legal in all cases and just over a quarter (27%) supported it being legal in most cases.

The poll of 1,000 US adults aged 18 to 69 revealed that mainline Protestants (18%) and Catholics (16%) were less likely than evangelicals to support a blanket ban on abortion. Just under a third of Protestants (31%) said they believed abortion should be illegal in most cases, slightly higher than Catholics holding the same view (28%).

Even among those who self-identified as pro-life, only a third (34%) of respondents said that abortion should be illegal in all cases, while over half (52%) said it should be illegal in most cases.

A quarter of all respondents described themselves as "pro-life", far lower than the 40% identifying as "pro-choice", although over a quarter (29%) said they were "neither or a mix of both". 

Of the respondents identifying as evangelical, nearly half (47%) identified as pro-life, far higher than a third of mainline Protestants and a quarter (27%) of Catholics. 

Only 18% of evangelicals said they were pro-choice, compared to a third of Catholics (34%) and a similar proportion of mainline Protestants (36%). 

Those who identified as "non-religious" were far more likely to describe themselves as pro-choice (53%), with only 14% saying they were pro-life. 

The survey also shed light on perceptions of when life begins, with evangelicals (42%) being far more likely than Catholics (31%), mainline Protestants (34%) and non-religious respondents (21%) to say that a fetus is a living being at the point of conception. 

Catholics (38%) were the most likely, though, to believe that a fetus becomes a living being from the first heartbeat, followed by evangelicals (36%) and mainline Protestants (30%). 

Even among non-religious respondents, over half (55%) agreed that a fetus can be regarded as a living being at the point when the heartbeat can be detected or earlier.

Dr Karysse Trandem, spokesperson for Save the Storks, said: "There's a disconnect in our culture right now.

"The majority of Americans believe that life begins at or before the heartbeat, but the majority of evangelicals and Catholics identify as pro-choice."

Save the Storks President Paul Isaacs said: "We hope this research is the beginning of an honest dialogue among Christians.

"We are going to have to work harder to equip the next generation of Christians to have a more life-affirming ethic on this issue."

News
Catholic affiliation falls across Latin America as religious 'nones' grow 
Catholic affiliation falls across Latin America as religious 'nones' grow 

But belief in God remains widespread, a new study has found.

£90,000 raised to support Spurgeon’s College students after sudden closure
£90,000 raised to support Spurgeon’s College students after sudden closure

Spurgeon’s College, one of the UK’s oldest theological institutions, closed with immediate effect in July 2025.

Iranian Christian sisters freed from federal detention in the US
Iranian Christian sisters freed from federal detention in the US

Two Iranian Christian sisters who were detained by federal authorities last month under accusations that they entered the country illegally have been freed while their cases proceed.

Assisted suicide laws suffer setbacks in England, Scotland and France
Assisted suicide laws suffer setbacks in England, Scotland and France

Campaigners in favour of medically assisted suicide in England, Scotland and France have apparently suffered setbacks that could ensure the controversial practice never comes into law.