Online Safety Bill 'could censor Christian teaching'

The Christian Institute fears that Big Tech corporations will go beyond the requirements of the law. (Photo: Unsplash/Joshua Hoehne)

Government plans to curtail access to harmful online content could also lead to the censorship of Christian teaching, it has been warned.

The Christian Institute has welcomed the government's commitment to clamping down on websites promoting harmful content like porn or suicide, but says it fears that voicing Christian beliefs may fall foul of the regulations.

Measures in the Online Safety Bill will restrict content deemed "harmful" but The Christian Institute expressed concern that the definition of this term will be left to the government, Ofcom and private tech companies like Google and Facebook.

The Christian Institute warned that without robust free speech protections, the legislation "could have unintended consequences" and "censor Christian teaching" on issues like sexuality, gender and marriage.

Institute Director Colin Hart said the Bill "risks enshrining cancel culture into law".

"Every day we hear accusations that someone is causing harm just for saying what they believe. The eminent Christian doctor, Peter Saunders, had a talk on transsexuality removed by YouTube. JK Rowling was vilified for challenging transgender ideology," he said. 

"Maya Forstater lost her job after saying that people cannot change their biological sex. At her Employment Tribunal the judge found against Forstater and said her view was 'not worthy of respect in a democratic society'. Thankfully, this was overturned.

"But imagine consolidating that power in the hands of Big Tech.

"They will get to decide what should and shouldn't be allowed in crucial and controversial areas of debate. Their yardstick will be their own commercial interest and so will inevitably go much further than what the law requires," he said. 

Mr Hart warned that unless free speech protections are strengthened in the Bill, mainstream Christian beliefs on sexual ethics, gender, marriage and parenting could end up being censored. 

"The Bill must be amended to include a presumption in favour of free speech. What is free to say on 'the street' must also remain free to say online," he said. 

"The legislation also proposes a new criminal offence for communication deemed 'likely to cause harm to a likely audience'. This risks putting harm into the eye of the beholder.

"Any approach that prioritises the claims of the 'offended' is dangerous, particularly when the 'likely audience' for online content could be anyone in the world. The Bill risks enshrining cancel culture into law."

News
250 doctors and nurses in Wales urge Senedd to vote against assisted suicide
250 doctors and nurses in Wales urge Senedd to vote against assisted suicide

While the Welsh Parliament cannot stop the bill, they may be able to make Westminster think twice.

Coalition of 13 aid agencies urge UK action as Sudan war reaches 1,000-day mark
Coalition of 13 aid agencies urge UK action as Sudan war reaches 1,000-day mark

Humanitarian organisations have renewed calls for urgent UK government intervention as the conflict in Sudan passes 1,000 days, warning that the country is now facing the biggest humanitarian crisis in the world.

Fulani herdsmen kill 13 Christians in central Nigeria
Fulani herdsmen kill 13 Christians in central Nigeria

Fulani herdsmen arrived at midnight on Monday and shot four Christians who had been asleep in their homes.

Franklin Graham asks for prayers for US amid ICE tensions
Franklin Graham asks for prayers for US amid ICE tensions

The Rev Franklin Graham is calling on Americans to join him in a “time of prayer and repentance” this week, warning that “our nation is in trouble” amid a volatile political climate.