'No human being is illegal': Linguists decry use of 'illegal immigrants' to tag people who enter U.S. without papers

How does one describe the nearly 11 million people living in the United States without proper documents?

In 2010, Latinos and immigration activists marched in Phoenix to protest SB1070, which was termed as the "show me your papers" law. One sign said, "No human being is illegal."

Over the years, a dispute has risen on the proper term to be used in describing undocumented immigrants.

Otto Santa Ana, a linguist and professor in the University of California's Department of Chicana/o Studies, and other linguists said using the phrase "illegal immigrants" is neither "accurate nor neutral," reported The Guardian.

"We don't call pedestrians who cross in the middle of the road illegal pedestrians," he said. "A kid who skips school to go to Disneyland is not an illegal student. And yet that's a sort of parallel."

Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton became involved in the issue during a Facebook Q&A when Pulitzer-prize winning journalist and immigration activist Jose Antonio Vargas asked her to stop using "illegal immigrant."

He said Clinton used the term at a New Hampshire campaign event. Clinton admitted that it was a "poor choice of words" and promised not to use the phrase again.

"As I've said throughout this campaign, the people at the heart of this issue are children, parents, families, DREAMers. They have names, and hopes and dreams that deserve to be respected," she said.

Vargas, an undocumented immigrant, was surprised to hear Clinton use the phrase as she made immigration a major programme in her campaign.

"I am here illegally, without legal status, without authorisation. Those are facts. I as a person am not illegal because people can't be illegal. Calling people illegal is not only factually inaccurate, it's journalistically irresponsible," said Vargas who came to the U.S. from the Philippines as a child.

Vargas recently launched the #WordsMatter campaign aiming to encourage all the 2016 presidential candidates to drop the phrase "illegal immigrants."

Former Maryland governor Martin O'Malley, another Democratic presidential candidate, decried Clinton's use of the phrase and joined the campaign.

"I have always called immigrants New Americans because that is what they are," he said.

Republican candidate Donald Trump often includes "illegal aliens" in his speech, which activists say is offensive.

Jeb Bush was criticised for using the term "anchor babies" to describe children who are born in the U.S. to undocumented parents.

José Luis Benavides, a journalism professor at California State University, Northridge, said for many Americans, "illegal immigrant" is synonymous with Mexican, and specifically someone who crossed the U.S. southern border unlawfully.

Since 2008, the report said, more immigrants overstayed their visas than crossed the U.S. border legally. In the last five years, more immigrants returned to Mexico from the U.S. than migrated north.

Almost 11 percent of the undocumented population in the U.S., or 1.3 million, are from Asia.

related articles
Decorated sheriff accuses President Obama of apathy in enforcing immigration laws
Decorated sheriff accuses President Obama of apathy in enforcing immigration laws

Decorated sheriff accuses President Obama of apathy in enforcing immigration laws

US accused of poorly treating women and children in immigration detention centres
US accused of poorly treating women and children in immigration detention centres

US accused of poorly treating women and children in immigration detention centres

Donald Trump says all illegal immigrants in  the US must be deported: \'They have to go\'
Donald Trump says all illegal immigrants in the US must be deported: 'They have to go'

Donald Trump says all illegal immigrants in the US must be deported: 'They have to go'

\'Illegal immigrants\': Why if I hear that again I will scream
'Illegal immigrants': Why if I hear that again I will scream

'Illegal immigrants': Why if I hear that again I will scream

10 US states plus Washington, D.C. allow illegal immigrants to get driver\'s licenses
10 US states plus Washington, D.C. allow illegal immigrants to get driver's licenses

10 US states plus Washington, D.C. allow illegal immigrants to get driver's licenses

Pope Francis likely to get a mixed welcome from US Congress
Pope Francis likely to get a mixed welcome from US Congress

Pope Francis likely to get a mixed welcome from US Congress

Pope tells Congress US should reject hostility to immigrants
Pope tells Congress US should reject hostility to immigrants

Pope tells Congress US should reject hostility to immigrants

European Union talks tough on deportations amid surge in Syrian refugees
European Union talks tough on deportations amid surge in Syrian refugees

European Union talks tough on deportations amid surge in Syrian refugees

News
Joseph Duggar of '19 Kids and Counting' arrested for child molestation
Joseph Duggar of '19 Kids and Counting' arrested for child molestation

Former “19 Kids and Counting” star Joseph Duggar, whose older brother Josh Duggar is currently serving time in prison for receiving and possessing child pornography, has been arrested and charged with lewd and lascivious behavior involving unlawful sexual activity with a minor.

Bangladesh Christian leaders express cautious hope under new government
Bangladesh Christian leaders express cautious hope under new government

Bangladesh’s new government has prompted cautious optimism among Christian leaders, who say recent political changes offer a potential opening for greater religious freedom even as concerns remain over security, justice and political pressure.

Scotland’s assisted suicide vote: a temporary victory?
Scotland’s assisted suicide vote: a temporary victory?

It will be interesting to see if the Scottish government goes down the route of investing in quality palliative care, or whether Liam McArthur's defeated assisted suicide bill is simply resurrected in another form.

Nick Timothy stands by criticism of Muslim prayer in Trafalgar Square
Nick Timothy stands by criticism of Muslim prayer in Trafalgar Square

Shadow justice minister Nick Timothy is standing by claims that a mass Islamic prayer in Trafalgar Square was “a declaration of domination” that should never be repeated.