Every Catholic bishop should watch 'Spotlight', says former Vatican sex abuse prosecutor

All bishops and cardinals in the Roman Catholic Church should watch the film Spotlight, according to the Church's former main prosecutor in child sex abuse cases against priests.

Archbishop of Malta Charles Scicluna said: "All bishops and cardinals must see this film, especially those in charge of souls, because they have to understand that it is the complaint that will save the Church, not the conspiracy of silence."

Spotlight shows the investigation by the Boston Globe's Spotlight team between 2001 and 2002 into clerical sex abuse in the US city, and how the team overcame numerous attempts to cover it up. 

"The movie shows how the instinct – that unfortunately was present in the Church – to protect a reputation was completely wrong," Archbishop Scicluna  told La Repubblica after a showing of the film in Valletta, Malta.

Before moving to Malta, first as an auxiliary, Scicluna, aged 56, worked in Rome for 10 years, handling sex abuse accusations against priests.

In December 2002, Cardinal Law, Archbishop of Boston, resigned and moved to Rome.

The investigation uncovered 249 priests accused of abuse. By 2008, nearly 1,500 victims were known about.

Scicluna said: "The numbers are impressive. But the strength of this film is not the numbers, but one key word: omertà (silence). The film shows how the instinct, which was unfortunately present, to protect the Church's good name, was totally wrong. There can be no mercy without justice."

In the middle of the film, the journalist heading the investigation, Walter Robinson, played by Michael Keaton, says it takes a whole village to raise a child, and a whole village to abuse one.

Scicluna said: "The child is being abused by an adult, in this case by a priest, of course. But offenders are also those who know and do not speak."

He also recalled that four months after the Globe began publishing its stories, the then Pope, Benedict XVI, summoned all US cardinals and told them: "There is no place in the priesthood and religious life for priests or religious who abuse minors."

He said it was the beginning of a new era for the Church, and that he believed in God's mercy for all, even the guilty, but the basis of mercy in justice was truth.

related articles
Catholic sex abuse scandal news: St. Paul-Minneapolis archbishop resigns over sex abuse claims
Catholic sex abuse scandal news: St. Paul-Minneapolis archbishop resigns over sex abuse claims

Catholic sex abuse scandal news: St. Paul-Minneapolis archbishop resigns over sex abuse claims

Spotlight star Michael Keaton defends the Catholic faith

Spotlight star Michael Keaton defends the Catholic faith

Spotlight: a film that the whole church cannot – and must not – ignore
Spotlight: a film that the whole church cannot – and must not – ignore

Spotlight: a film that the whole church cannot – and must not – ignore

Pope\'s commission on sex abuse sits down to watch Spotlight
Pope's commission on sex abuse sits down to watch Spotlight

Pope's commission on sex abuse sits down to watch Spotlight

Chilean campaigner alleges sex abuse cover-up, asks Pope to sack bishop
Chilean campaigner alleges sex abuse cover-up, asks Pope to sack bishop

Chilean campaigner alleges sex abuse cover-up, asks Pope to sack bishop

Australian abuse victims crowdfund trip to Rome for Vatican treasurer testimony
Australian abuse victims crowdfund trip to Rome for Vatican treasurer testimony

Australian abuse victims crowdfund trip to Rome for Vatican treasurer testimony

News
Between two cultures: an Afghan Christian in the Netherlands
Between two cultures: an Afghan Christian in the Netherlands

Esther*, who was born in Afghanistan and raised in the Netherlands after her family fled the country when she was three, speaks to Christian Today about her journey of faith, life between two cultures, and her hopes and fears for Afghanistan’s future.

The groundbreaking BBC series that brought Jesus to TV screens
The groundbreaking BBC series that brought Jesus to TV screens

Seventy years ago, in February 1956, the BBC aired the mini-series “Jesus of Nazareth”, which was the first filming of the life of Jesus to be created for television. This is the story …

Christians mobilised to oppose extreme abortion law changes
Christians mobilised to oppose extreme abortion law changes

Christians are being asked to urge peers to support amendments tabled by Baronesses Monckton and Stroud.

Thousands of Christians return to churches in north-east Nigeria despite years of terror
Thousands of Christians return to churches in north-east Nigeria despite years of terror

The faithful are returning “in their thousands, not hundreds” despite more than a decade of brutal violence.