Darwin 'I don't believe the Bible' letter sells for record price

A letter in which Charles Darwin appears to confirm his atheism fetched $197,000 (£126,000) at auction yesterday

The sum was nearly three times the guide price and three times the previous record of $59,142 for a four-page letter that Darwin had sent to his niece.

Dated November 24, 1880, the letter was written in response to an enquiry from a Christian lawyer, Frederick McDermott.

McDermott wrote to Darwin saying that he would like to read his books, but that "I am a busy man & not at all a clever man, and if I am to have pleasure in reading your books I must feel that at the end I shall not have lost my faith in the New Testament". McDermott asked for a "yes or no" answer as to whether Darwin believed in the New Testament, adding: "So [if] you will write on the back of this page Yes or No you will be doing a real kindness which I will certainly not abuse by sending a paragraph to the theological papers headed 'Mr Darwin on the New Testament'."

Darwin answered, perhaps rather curtly but with more than McDermott had asked for, "'I am sorry to have to inform you that I do not believe in the Bible as a divine revelation & therefore not in Jesus Christ as the son of God."

Darwin's religious views were of considerable interest during his lifetime as his On the Origin of Species appeared to challenge the biblical account of creation in Genesis. He is often claimed as a champion by atheists, but was an orthodox Christian for the first part of his life before moving to an agnostic position.

In his Gore lecture on the 150th anniversary of the publication of the Origin of Species, Nick Spencer said Darwin was "never, even in his wildest fluctuations, an atheist full stop". However, he did not believe in a special Christian or biblical revelation, which he states in his answer to McDermott.

Spencer also says Darwin "was a man who has been hijacked for the cause of modern atheism in a way that he would have been profoundly uncomfortable with".

related articles
First edition of Origin of the Species sells at auction for £26,000
First edition of Origin of the Species sells at auction for £26,000

First edition of Origin of the Species sells at auction for £26,000

The great dinosaur scam: Christian mother launches Mumsnet tirade
The great dinosaur scam: Christian mother launches Mumsnet tirade

The great dinosaur scam: Christian mother launches Mumsnet tirade

In Louisiana, students read the Book of Genesis in their science classes
In Louisiana, students read the Book of Genesis in their science classes

In Louisiana, students read the Book of Genesis in their science classes

Can Christians believe in dinosaurs?
Can Christians believe in dinosaurs?

Can Christians believe in dinosaurs?

Why it\'s time to lose the fish car sticker
Why it's time to lose the fish car sticker

Why it's time to lose the fish car sticker

Francis on climate change: \'We can no longer turn our backs on reality\'
Francis on climate change: 'We can no longer turn our backs on reality'

Francis on climate change: 'We can no longer turn our backs on reality'

Professor at Christian college resigns after it insists on anti-evolution statement
Professor at Christian college resigns after it insists on anti-evolution statement

Professor at Christian college resigns after it insists on anti-evolution statement

News
Christians welcome plans to crackdown on AI deepfake pornography
Christians welcome plans to crackdown on AI deepfake pornography

Elon Musk said the scandal was being used as an "excuse for censorship".

Calls to end puberty blockers experimentation on children by the NHS
Calls to end puberty blockers experimentation on children by the NHS

“Puberty blockers are the first step down a medical path with extremely dangerous lifelong consequences.”

850-year-old cathedral choir school closes following Labour's VAT assault
850-year-old cathedral choir school closes following Labour's VAT assault

Exeter Cathedral School, which has operated for over 850 years, has announced that it will be closing its doors due to “unavoidable financial pressures”.

Geographer says evidence to support Noah’s Ark theory is inconclusive
Geographer says evidence to support Noah’s Ark theory is inconclusive

A Turkish geographer has urged caution over recent media reports suggesting that pottery fragments discovered near a boat-shaped geological formation in eastern Turkey could confirm the existence of Noah’s Ark, saying the findings are preliminary and require further scientific study.