Catholic priests are refusing to serve as bishops, says senior cleric

Catholic priests tipped for the office of bishop are declining the appointment, according to the National Catholic Reporter (NCR).

Cardinal Marc Ouellet, prefect of the Congregation for Bishops – the department of the Roman Curia that oversees the selection of bishops – told NCR it was no longer "exceptional" for priests to decline to serve.

Asked about rumours more priests were declining the role, he said: "Yes, that's true. Nowadays you have people who do not accept the appointment."

He said the number was "not huge" and that priests decline for different reasons. Ouellet gave the example of a priest who was chosen, but said he had cancer. "It was a sign of responsibility not to accept the appointment," he said.

Others, he said, decline because of something in their past or because they think they cannot handle the responsibility. He said that in the latter case the Congregation of Bishops would normally insist that they accept the appointment because people are often not the best judges of their own abilities. However, said Ouellet, when a priest made "a decision in conscience", the Vatican respected it.

As well as appointing new bishops – in a process that requires papal approval – the Congregation also arranges five-yearly visits of bishops to Rome, where they meet with Pope Francis.

Ouellet told NCR the pope "has insisted on the pastoral quality of the bishops. That's very clear. It does not mean that they do not have to be masters of the faith because a bishops is, first and foremost, the first teacher of the faith in his diocese." However, "the capacity to relate to people, to establish dialogue, to start from the point where people are – this is a quality that is also requested", he said.

New bishops are required to attend an eight- or nine-day course in Rome involving both practical and spiritual input.

"The goal of these meetings is to learn their new identity – that they belong to the college of the successors of the apostles," Ouellet said. "It's an extraordinary moment of conversion for them."

The Roman Catholic Church has more than 5,000 bishops around the world and around 414,000 priests.

related articles
Pope Francis: Christians cannot \'bargain\' with God
Pope Francis: Christians cannot 'bargain' with God

Pope Francis: Christians cannot 'bargain' with God

Pope Francis urges nuns and priests to avoid dropping a 'gossip bomb'

Pope Francis urges nuns and priests to avoid dropping a 'gossip bomb'

Pope Francis is to make his movie debut, but not as an actor

Pope Francis is to make his movie debut, but not as an actor

Man accused of posing as a priest and stealing from parishioners has been arrested
Man accused of posing as a priest and stealing from parishioners has been arrested

Man accused of posing as a priest and stealing from parishioners has been arrested

News
Christians react to US capture of Maduro
Christians react to US capture of Maduro

Some Christian leaders have been enthusiastic about US actions in Venezuela, while others have been more cautious.

Church community projects linked to falling antisocial behaviour and crime
Church community projects linked to falling antisocial behaviour and crime

A Croydon council estate once known locally for disorder and intimidation has seen markedly better trends in crime and antisocial behaviour over the past decade, with a new study suggesting sustained church-led community projects played a significant role.

Over a million Australians attend church each week - study
Over a million Australians attend church each week - study

New national data suggests Australia’s churches are continuing a gradual recovery in weekly attendance following the COVID-19 pandemic, while still falling short of levels seen at the turn of the millennium.

Abortion was leading cause of death worldwide in 2025
Abortion was leading cause of death worldwide in 2025

More than 73 million abortions were performed worldwide in 2025, making abortion the leading cause of death last year. The figure draws on World Health Organization estimates compiled by the global data-tracking platform Worldometers.