Catholic priest compares paedophiles to women who commit adultery

A Catholic priest has compared priests who have committed sexual offences to women who commit adultery. 

According to Father Bill Edebohls, a Roman Catholic parish priest at Malvern East in Melbourne, Australia, the media and lawyers are a "baying crowd" who fail to understand the need for both justice and mercy.

He called for priests who have committed sexual offences to be treated with "justice drenched in mercy".

Edebohls, a convert from Anglicanism and former Dean of Ballarat, referred to Australia's Royal Commission into child sex abuse.

"Part of my concern with the current royal commission on the institutional sexual abuse of minors is that we may in the end gain justice for the victims but they will be denied healing," he said in his sermon, reproduced on the website of his local church school, The Age reported.

"Why? Because both the media and the lawyers, like the baying crowd of men in the gospel ready to throw stones, don't understand the need for a justice that is drenched in mercy."

Referring to the gospel story about the woman caught in adultery, quoting Jesus: "He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her."

He continued: "For our generation, where adultery is not regarded as a crime – and many have lost the moral sense of the destructive harm adultery does to family and community – and the media dish adultery up night after night as playful entertainment – we probably don't get the power of the gospel story nor the dramatic effect on the characters in the story.

"Remember this was a sin, a crime that carried the death penalty – by stoning. Maybe to get the real drama and effect of the story we ought to replace the adulterous woman with a paedophile priest. Then we might begin to understand the mob eager to stone and the outrageous and profligate mercy and compassion of God ever ready to forgive."

Shane Healy, spokesman for the Catholic archdiocese of Melbourne, defended Edebohls. He said: "He tried to pick a contemporary example of what might have been a woman adulterer of 2000 years ago, who would have been looked on entirely differently."

related articles
Australian priest raped victims weekly, abuse enquiry hears

Australian priest raped victims weekly, abuse enquiry hears

Paedophile priests collaborated to hide abuse revealed in confessional

Paedophile priests collaborated to hide abuse revealed in confessional

Pope accepts resignation of Australian bishop accused of cover-up over child sex abuse
Pope accepts resignation of Australian bishop accused of cover-up over child sex abuse

Pope accepts resignation of Australian bishop accused of cover-up over child sex abuse

Horrific catalogue of child sexual abuse by Christian Brothers in Australia
Horrific catalogue of child sexual abuse by Christian Brothers in Australia

Horrific catalogue of child sexual abuse by Christian Brothers in Australia

Cardinal Pell and supporters hit back at abuse allegations
Cardinal Pell and supporters hit back at abuse allegations

Cardinal Pell and supporters hit back at abuse allegations

\'The Church has let people down.\' Cardinal Pell child abuse testimony
'The Church has let people down.' Cardinal Pell child abuse testimony

'The Church has let people down.' Cardinal Pell child abuse testimony

News
SNP 'conversion therapy' ban would be 'fundamentally illiberal'
SNP 'conversion therapy' ban would be 'fundamentally illiberal'

SNP support has dropped, but they are still the frontrunners for next month's elections.

Franklin Graham pushes back against Pope's war comments amid war of words with Trump
Franklin Graham pushes back against Pope's war comments amid war of words with Trump

Graham told Piers Morgan that while he did not want or support war, there was justification for it "when you're fighting evil".

Archbishop of Canterbury joins Pope in call for peace
Archbishop of Canterbury joins Pope in call for peace

The Pope has been outspoken against the latest war in the Middle East.

Church warden murder conviction quashed as Court of Appeal orders retrial
Church warden murder conviction quashed as Court of Appeal orders retrial

The Court of Appeal has overturned the murder conviction of Benjamin Field, the former church warden jailed in 2019 for the death of university lecturer Peter Farquhar, in a significant ruling that reopens one of the UK’s most complex criminal cases.